It's the same fingers Diabolik. It's just that the angle of the thumb is different in the first pic and that makes it look like it's from the other hand.
Btw, they are $5.99 Canadian at the Micheal's up here, but they are all sold out now. I used them for my halloween party invites, along with the toe tags that someone posted up here (thanks for those btw)

They were a big hit. I picked up two bags (50% off with their coupons). .... one for the party invites (one per family), and the other bag is going into my custom fogger bowl complete with floating eye balls. (pics to follow in my $1 Tombstone thread)
And yes, the fingerprints are a nice touch. I guess the were actually molded from someone's fingers. Hmm, now that I think about it, I wonder if the police would be able to trace them back to the original owner? lol